BWV 1041, Concerto for Violin and Orchestra in A minor
It would be difficult to match the elegance of these pieces (the violin concertos, unless one were to listen to Bach's harpsichord concertos which came before--sometime in Coethen, which I guess I will talk about later).
The energy of the first movement is exciting. The motives rush forward like waves, not to be corny or anything. These pieces always make me wish that I was proficient enough at the keyboard to fill out a continuo line. Maybe that will be a goal for next year.
The middle movement of 1041 has always struck me as somewhat profound even the orchestral writing alone. The dirge of its motion seems most like Bach particularly his writing in some of the cantata movements and in some movements of the passions. Then again, the first time I listened to this movement, which was a couple of years ago, I didn't think that it sounded like Bach. It was at the final cadence of this middle movement that I wondered if Bach was giving us a picture of what was to come. Although nothing of this is out of the ordinary for Bach's time, but I was left to wonder. It was almost like this dirge was heavier, almost Russian in a sense; this may sound ridiculous to most of you.
The final movement is filled with energy just like the first movement. The counterpoint is Bach's signature work. The solo violin plays an ornamented line that is indicative of the time. I listen to this and imagine the grand architecture of the high Baroque. The piece ends strongly in a minor, PAC.
BWV 1042, Concerto for Violin and Orchestra in E Major
The first motive of this work is a major triad. How exciting. I don't compose much, particularly because of composers like Bach. The intimidation is too much! However, when I do compose I try to do as much as I can with the simplest melody that I can come up with. I have told my choir that there is much that can be done with a single scale. All this to say, that Bach elucidates the importance of the simple motives like a major triad in this case by developing these motives. Here comes the motive in the cellos, and wait is that now in the violas--all the while the solo instrument is playing the accompanying line. A section moving into B section.
Triad after triad after triad... finally a cadence and then more development. What a cadence in the B section. Da capo? It sounds like it, or some version of it. Large group/small group with soloist. Back to A. Strong cadence! Decoration, ornamentation...
Middle movement: lush. Without a score in front of me, I don't feel like I could intelligently discuss it's harmonic motion. However, like most of Bach, it is somewhat unpredictable within predictable parameters. One of the reasons for composing middle movements like these is to provide somewhat of a respite between the more highly energetic movements. This is common in concerto form. Composers do it all the time. I hate to say this because I know it's probably not a good musician thing to say, but sometimes I wish that these more decadent lush movements were at the end of a work. Nothing leaves me more fulfilled than these emotional escapes. Now, I must say that it isn't that the other movements are lacking emotion. But the place to which I am drawn in these slower movements in both 1041 and 1042 is a good place, a nice place, I wouldn't mind staying there just a little longer.
The last movement ends with the energy of the first movement. The motives are similar in many ways. It seems that maybe Bach spun out the melody from the first movement just a little more. However, I could be completely wrong. The similarities are there nonetheless.
Reading the liner notes, I am reminded that Bach was influenced by Vivaldi. My listening today makes me want to listen to the Four Seasons. I have never actually listened to that work. Although, I have heard Spring many times on commercials and as ring-tones.
Today's recording was Isaac Stern and the English Chamber Orchestra. Inspiring recording from the 70s. Not sure what's next... probably the Double Concerto and Violin and Oboe.